It judges them. The issue is muddied further by people complaining about the broadcasts themselves — who got to sing what and with what prominence — with the inherent obligation of an award show to focus on what someone has pre-decided to be excellent.
Otherwise, they cease to be award shows. Like newspaper critics speaking of things in decline the award-giving entities are reliant on the voluntary respect of their constituency. Otherwise they have no power. And no reason to exist. What you are currently watching or not watching is the slow erosion of that respect. Consider the diversity dilemma, for example. An enlightened studio might respond to such protests by, say, renewing its commitment to diversity and greenlighting more work by artists of color.
It could put out a news release to that effect, hire new directors and commit resources. Some of that, thankfully, has been taking place. They have to wait for those movies to be made and hope that they rise to the top. And if they are to be fair to the kind of movies that have historically won Oscars, and they have no other choice but to be so, given that they claim to recognize excellence across the board, they may still have to give the Oscar to, say, an old favorite like Meryl Streep.
And, if necessary, take it on the chin. And in the ratings. You might argue that the awards shows can combat their problems by changing who decides who wins what. There is real truth there: The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, for example, is famously older and whiter than the audience. There is clear evidence this impacts who wins what. This should be the real target of the protests — never the winners in any given year, but the perennial list of deciders. Would you want to be given a Grammy for callow political reasons?
What artist deserves that? So too with the best new artist category. She may have been snubbed for one big honour, but her song and record of the year nominations are still likely to resonate at the sales counter for weeks afterward.
Greg Kot is the music critic at the Chicago Tribune. His work can be found here. If you would like to comment on this story or anything else you have seen on BBC Culture, head over to our Facebook page or message us on Twitter. On the Record Pop music. Why do the Grammy Awards get it wrong?
Justin Bieber. I am very meticulous and intentional about my music. To be clear I absolutely love Pop music it just wasn't what I set out to make this time around. My gratitude for feeling respected for my work remains and I am honored to be nominated either way. Teyana Taylor. Taylor, Kehlani and Walker all did not receive Grammy nominations this year, but Aiko earned three, including one in the Big Four category of album of the year for Chilombo. Despite Manic spawning the Billboard Hot topping single "Without Me," Halsey spoke out about her Grammys snub on her Instagram Story and, like Zayn, wished for fewer "handshakes" and more transparency in the process behind the nominations.
The two-time Grammy-nominated singer added that many politics go into receiving a nod, including "committing to exclusive TV performances" that help the Recording Academy earn "millions in advertising on the night of the show. But I'm sure this post will blacklist me anyway. Drake showed some major crew love to The Weeknd following his surprising shutout at the Grammys, but 6 God let the record show he doesn't believe this awards show, which "once was the highest form of recognition," has remained relevant to the artists who are thought to be deserving of it.
The time Grammy nominee has gained nods in each of the Big Four categories -- best new artist in , record of the year for "Work" with Rihanna in and "God's Plan" in , song of the year for "God's Plan" and album of the year for his contributions on Minaj's Loud in , Kendrick Lamar's Good Kid, M.
However, he's only won four Grammys since , and they've all been in the rap categories. The Grammy-nominated rapper sought out justice for the late Pop Smoke's posthumous album Shoot for the Stars Aim for the Moon , which he executive produced and was notably left out of the album of the year and best rap album categories at the Grammy Awards. In a since-deleted Instagram post, 50 Cent expressed his disappointment toward the Recording Academy, describing it as "out of touch.
Just two weeks before the Grammy nominations were announced, in an interview with Spotify's RapCaviar, Fif predicted Pop's project might get snubbed at the awards show. They didn't recognize mine. They're afraid to give [Pop Smoke] Grammys because they think it's teaching the audience to want to be like Pop. And to be like him is to be a part of gang culture. Who you see get Grammys that is making drill music? You mean to tell me ain't none of those songs worthy of it?
Those platforms are not for them to acknowledge. It's for the culture, the people to embrace those tones and to really appreciate the artist for doing that. Ellie Goulding. The English singer-songwriter started a longer conversation about the music industry by writing a piece on Medium shortly after the Grammy nominations were called. People are being awarded -- in the form of both nominations and category wins -- for reasons that are hard to decipher," she wrote.
The three-time Grammy-winning MC explicitly called out the Academy for its lack of diversity and transparency. Tyler, The Creator. After his one and only Grammy win for best rap album Igor , Tyler called out the Recording Academy backstage for the nomenclature behind the categories Black artists typically dominate.
It's just a politically correct way to say the N-word to me Half of me feels like the rap nomination was a backhanded compliment. The time Grammy-winning MC talked to Sway Calloway in about how the Grammys suck the blood out of artists by requesting their attendance to an awards show they won't win at. I don't think it's a big deal now," Eminem said. Please do not ask me. My answer is no for a million years.
Never again will I fing go to the Grammys," he stated. Ariana Grande. Grande chose not to perform at the Grammy Awards and disclosed her side of the story after disputing an Associated Press interview with the ceremony's former producer Ken Ehrlich, who's quoted as saying the the singer "felt it was too late to put something together for the show. Grande was nominated for best pop vocal album Sweetener and best pop solo performance "God Is a Woman" that year. She ended up winning the former.
Stepping up, and also stepping aside. And every year before this," she wrote. Sheryl Crow. Like P!
0コメント